Ankle

Tibia Stress Fracture

search

Tibia Stress Fracture, Tibial Stress Fracture, Dreaded Black Line

  • See Also
  1. Stress Fracture
  2. Running Injury
  • Epidemiology
  1. Most common Stress Fracture
    1. Accounts for >50% of Stress Fractures
  2. Common overuse injury in runners and jumpers
  • Risk Factors
  1. Female Athlete Triad
  2. Associated sporting activities (esp. anterior, mid-Tibial Stress Fractures)
    1. Jumping sports
    2. Distance runners
    3. Basketball
    4. Ballet
    5. Military recruits
  • Differential Diagnosis
  1. Shin Splints
  2. Exertional Compartment Syndrome
  • Types
  1. Posteromedial Stress Fractures (most common)
    1. Occur on compressive side of tibia
    2. Associated with overall good prognosis and healing
  2. Anterior cortical Fractures (uncommon to rare)
    1. Occur on tension side of tibia (poor vascular supply)
    2. High risk for nonunion and complete Fracture
  • Symptoms
  1. Insidious onset of dull aching pain in the anterior midtibial shaft
  2. Starts with pain during and immediately after intense activity
  3. Progresses to constant pain interfering with daily activity
  4. Nocturnal pain also develops
  • Findings
  • Symptoms and Signs
  1. Extremely tender focal area of tibia (e.g. over anterior tibial crest)
  2. Palpable thickened Nodule (hypertrophic periosteal response) may be present at Stress Fracture site
  3. Provocative maneuvers
    1. Pain on application of vibrating tuning fork
    2. One legged Hop Test induced pain
      1. Test Sensitivity: 72%
      2. Test Specificity: 37%
    3. Heal thump or percussion induced pain
      1. Technique
        1. Patient lies supine with extended legs
        2. Examiner passively raises patient's leg 6 inches above exam table
        3. Examiner strikes patient's heel with the flat of their palm
        4. Positive if pain at anterior tibia
      2. Efficacy
        1. Test Sensitivity: 17%
        2. Test Specificity: 90%
    4. Pain with local Ultrasound at 2.5 to 3 W/cm2
      1. Not recommended currently for initial diagnosis
      2. Boam (1996) J Am Board Fam Pract 9:414-7 [PubMed]
  4. Common locations of Stress Fracture
    1. Children: Anterior proximal one third of tibia
    2. Adults: Junction of middle and distal third of tibia
  • Diagnostics
  1. XRay with cone down view
    1. Horizontal lucency (Dreaded Black Line)
      1. Seen more often in jumping sports, distance runners, basketball, ballet, military recruits
      2. Higher likelihood of nonunion or progression to complete Fracture
      3. Transverse Fracture through entire anterior shaft
        1. Anterior cortical Fractures occur on tension side of tibia (poor vascular supply)
        2. Contrast with more common posteromedial Stress Fractures on compressive side of tibia
  2. Triple phase bone scan
    1. Focal hot spot at point of maximal tenderness
  3. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) Tibia
  • Management
  • Anterior Tibial Stress Fracture (Dreaded Black Line)
  1. See Stress Fracture
  2. Precautions: High risk for complications (non-union, complete Fracture)
    1. Subset of Stress Fractures, on tension side of tibia with high risk of non-union or complete Fracture
    2. Contrast with the more common posteromedial Stress Fracture on the tibial compressive side
  3. Aggressive management to prevent complications
    1. Immediate, mechanical offloading, with strict non-weight bearing and Crutches
    2. Tall Walking Boot (CAM) or padded posterior splint to control ankle motion
  4. Follow-up
    1. Referral to orthopedics or sports medicine
    2. High risk for failed conservative therapy requiring surgical management
      1. Prophylactic intramedullary nailing
      2. Sclerotic bone excision with bone grafting
  • Management
  • Posteriomedial Tibial Stress Fracture
  1. See Stress Fracture
  2. Activity
    1. Avoid Running for 6-8 weeks
    2. May weight bear unless painful
    3. Slow, graded return to activity
    4. Return to sport may be as long as 3-10 months
      1. Robertson (2015) Br Med Bull 114(1):95-111 [PubMed]
  3. Other measures
    1. Consider Aircast Splinting
    2. Cast mid-shaft Fractures until pain-free
    3. Surgical repair indicated for delayed healing >6 months
  • Prognosis
  1. Anterior Fracture is high risk for non-union (contrast with posteromedial Fractures)
  • References
  1. Riveros (2026) Crit Dec Emerg Med 40(4): 22-3
  2. Arnold (2018) Am Fam Physician 97(8): 510-6 [PubMed]